Our Lady of Consolation R. C. Church

Parish was separated from St. Stanislaus Kostka's parish in 1909 as a separate Polish parish for Williamsburg. Prior to the erection of the church, mass was held at McCaddin Memorial Hall. The cornerstone of the church was laid on May 9, 19101 . The building combines a church and a school, with the basement used as a parish hall and a separate convent next door and rectory across Metropolitan Avenue. Church seats 800; school had 400 students and was run by the Felician Sisters. The founding pastor was Alexius A. Jarka. 2

In 1920, Robert J. Reiley completed plans for a three-story addition to the church. The addition is described as being on the north side of North 1st Street and costing $60,000. This likely describes the brick structures on North 1st Street that house the school, and may have replaced the earlier (1910) school structure.3

Original design of church is attributed to Reiley & Steinback based on their documented work designing the school and rectory as well as the later addition to the church; no documentation of architect for church (which may in fact be part of the same building with the school).

  • 1"Bishop Lays Cornerstone", Brooklyn Daily Eagle (May 10, 1910), 27.
  • 2 The Catholic Church in the United States of America, Volume III, New York: The Catholic Editing Co. (1914), 575.
  • 3 "Contemplated Construction", Real Estate Record and Builders' Guide (7 February 1920), 155.

184 Metropolitan Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11249
United States